It responds to the actual meaning of the postNot its keywords. A reply that misses a joke or sarcasm reads as automated instantly.

It adds something the post did not haveA reason, number, condition, example, or resource. If the author could have written it as a second paragraph, it is filler.

It does not begin by restating the postSummaries feel like padding. Start at your point, not theirs.

It names a specific situation instead of a crowd claimSwap “everyone,” “most people,” “nobody” for a case you can defend.

It claims no experience you do not haveInvented expertise is the fastest way to lose a thread when someone checks.

It sounds like you, not like a templateYour normal formality, sentence length, and vocabulary. Read it aloud — if you would not say it, do not post it.

It is short enough to invite a responseA reply is a hand extended, not a speech. Two to four sentences is usually enough.

Disagreement targets the claim, not the personName the exact point, offer the alternative, concede what you agree with.

It would survive being read out of contextReplies travel. Assume the least charitable screenshot.

Nothing about it is automated without reviewVolume without review trips X’s spam heuristics and your audience’s patience at the same time.

–

Tick the checks to score your reply

Score updates as you tick. There is no submit button and nothing leaves this page.

How the score is banded

The bands are deliberately strict — they describe a reply worth posting, not a reply that merely avoids trouble.

Score	Band	What it means
9–10	Post it	The reply adds something only you could add. This is the standard worth holding.
7–8	Fix one thing first	Usually c4 or c7: get specific, or get shorter. A one-minute edit.
5–6	Rewrite	The reply is safe but filler. Pick one pattern — reason, example, condition, question — and rebuild it.
0–4	Do not post	This is the generic agreement the timeline already drowns in. It costs your account more than it earns.

Where this checklist comes from. The ten checks compress the same criteria used across our writing guides: the 30-second editing pass, the six annotated reply patterns, and the account-risk rules in what X’s automation rules actually allow. For how much of the workflow you can safely automate, see automating replies without spamming.

Drafting fifty replies a week?

TweetReplier drafts inside X, learns your voice, and never posts without you — the review step this checklist automates the slow way.

Add to Chrome — Free

The reply quality checklist

How the score is banded